On March 1, 2010, country music artist Jerrod Niemann released his cover version under the title "Lover, Lover." The song is Niemann's first release on the Sea Gayle label, a sister label of Arista Nashville, as well as his fourth single release overall. Niemann's recording of the song features nine vocal tracks, all of which he recorded himself and then overdubbed. He recorded eight of the vocal tracks in one day and, after medicating his vocal cords, he recorded the bass backing vocals the next day.